ESSEX, Conn.—
In search of a method to treat her clients’ depression, Elizabeth
Hale-Rose has reached back some 2,500 years.
Sitting in a circle with five of her clients, the licensed clinical
social worker takes a page from the teachings of the Buddha.
“Close your eyes,” she says softly. “Place your hands in your lap or
on your legs ... make sure your head, neck and back are aligned ...
that your posture embodies dignity, stability, wakefulness and
willingness.”
She tells her clients to begin by attending to the sounds they hear.
“You don’t have to do anything,” she says. “We are simply here and
receptive to it.”
Hale-Rose practices at the Center for Psychotherapy Inc., which has
offices in Old Lyme, Essex and Guilford.
The technique she is using, known as mindfulness-based cognitive
therapy, is a cutting-edge approach to treating people with anxiety
and depression. Only a handful of therapists are doing it.
Developed in the late 1990s by a team of researchers led by Zindel
Segal, a professor of psychiatry and psychology at the University of
Toronto, the technique has been shown to be highly effective in
staving off repeated bouts of depression.
In 2000, Segal and two other researchers published a study of 145
patients showing that those who took an eight-week course to learn
how to practice mindfulness were half as likely to suffer a relapse
into depression over the next 12 months as those who received only
the usual treatment.
The technique was found to be most effective for those who have
suffered three or more episodes of depression before receiving it,
reducing the risk of relapse from 66 percent to 37 percent.
A follow-up study, published in 2002 by Teasdale and Helen Ma in
Cambridge, produced comparable results, showing the therapy reduced
the rate of relapse from 78 percent to 36 percent in those who had
three or more episodes of depression.
“I think that people that have only been depressed once or twice
think they can beat this on their own,” Segal said. “Three episodes
or more, you decide you really have to do something. Once you’ve had
depression a number of times, it becomes sort of autonomous. It
takes less to set it off.”
Nearly 19 million men and women have a depressive disorder in the
United States each year, with almost twice as many women suffering
as men, according to the National Institute of Mental Health. Less
than one-third of those people get treatment, in part, because of
the stigma that surrounds the illness, though, with treatment, many
people recover from it, according to the NIMH.
The most common treatments for depression include talking therapy,
in which the patient attempts to trace the roots of his or her
depression, and cognitive therapy, in which the patient learns how
to recognize and redirect destructive patterns of thinking.
Anti-depressant drugs are also used to treat depression. Usually,
patients will be treated with a combination of therapy and drugs.
Segal got the idea for his approach from the work of Jon Kabat-Zinn,
who established the Stress Reduction Clinic at the University of
Massachusetts Medical Center in Worcester, Mass., in 1979.
Kabat-Zinn used mindfulness and hatha yoga to help people suffering
chronic physical pain and medical problems, including headaches,
high blood pressure, back pain, heart disease, cancer and AIDS.
He described the program in a book, “Full Catastrophe Living,” and
says the technique is now being used at more than 200 medical
facilities around the world.
He has said the key to his approach is changing the “relationship”
to pain by accepting it and paying attention to it.
Practitioners of mindfulness learn to pull themselves back from
their pain or painful thoughts and observe what they’re thinking.
The focus is on the present moment, not the past nor the future.
Because the practice of mindfulness in treating depression is so
new, very few therapists use it, Segal says. He estimated the number
of people practicing it at “in the hundreds, at most.”
Hale-Rose, who uses traditional therapy in addition to mindfulness,
says the new approach often helps patients for whom more traditional
methods are less effective. Because she is a licensed clinical
social worker and the approach is coupled with traditional therapy,
the patient’s health insurance covers it.
One of those patients is 37-year-old Robert Koehler of Guilford. The
new method, he says, has been a godsend.
Depression had been a part of his life for many years, he says. He
had tried numerous anti-depressants but decided to quit them all
because of bad side effects such as increased anxiety and higher
blood pressure.
Koehler stayed with regular therapy until he learned of mindfulness
from Hale-Rose. Since taking the eight-week course with her , he has
practiced short, three-minute meditations three times a day. He does
longer, half-hour meditations three times a week.
“I feel good. I definitely enjoy it,” he says. “It seems trite to
say enlightened, but to somebody who’s spent most of their life
feeling negative, to say the least, to feel good most of the time is
definitely life-altering.”
click here to see Kenton Robinson's
full profile